Image source: Unsplash
Sooner or later, every energy leader figures out that the toughest calls are never only technical, only financial or only political. They land where all three meet, and customers sit in the middle of it. Karin Burns, an investor and energy executive who led a community choice energy provider in Southern California, has spent a good part of her career at that meeting point, where public policy goals, fast-moving technology and the daily needs of households and businesses all have to line up. Her experience shows how leaders can keep those three forces in balance.
Policy sets the direction, but implementation decides the result
Few industries are shaped by public policy as heavily as energy. Clean energy mandates, procurement requirements, rate structures and resource adequacy rules dictate what providers can build, buy and offer. California’s policies have steered the sector toward some of the most aggressive decarbonization targets anywhere, and that push has pulled huge sums of investment into renewable energy and storage.
A policy goal doesn’t produce results by itself, though. Whatever a legislature sets out still has to become contracts, projects, programs and rates that hold up in practice, and that conversion is where leadership earns its keep. Leaders have to understand what a policy is meant to accomplish and also how it plays against markets, existing infrastructure and the finances of the organizations charged with carrying it out.
Policy tends to work best when people who know implementation help shape it. After years of working with elected officials, regulators, utilities, community stakeholders, developers and industry partners, she has seen how much rides on leaders who can explain operational realities to policymakers and policy goals to staff and customers. That bridging work is mostly invisible, but things fall apart without it.
Technology is changing the possibilities faster than policy can follow
Meanwhile, technology is moving faster than policy can keep up. Battery storage is now central to resource planning. Rooftop solar, home batteries, smart thermostats, and electric vehicles are making customers active players on the grid, and flexible load management, demand response, and virtual power plants can pool thousands of small resources into real capacity.
All of this opens up big possibilities, and it also raises difficult questions. Which investments will pay off for every customer and not just the early adopters? How do you design programs so incentives reach the households that need them most? And how does an organization take on new tools without picking up risks it doesn’t fully understand?
Her organization ran straight into those questions. It committed to reaching 100% clean and renewable power by 2035 and built a portfolio backed by more than 1 GW of renewable power purchase agreements and 1.5 GW of battery storage agreements.
It also pushed into newer corners of the distributed energy economy, among them residential battery incentives, flexible load management, demand response and virtual power plant development. Every one of those efforts meant weighing what the technology promised against its cost, its risk and what it would do for customers, and technology alone couldn’t settle it.
Keeping customers at the center
The whole system exists for customers, and they see energy policy and technology in very plain terms. Is my power reliable? Is my bill fair? Can I trust the company that provides it? A strategy that forgets those questions can lose public support, however innovative or well meaning it is.
Putting customers at the center means building programs that are easy to follow and open to many different kinds of households. It calls for honesty about costs and tradeoffs. And it requires recognizing that customers aren’t one group, since renters, homeowners, small businesses and large commercial users all come with different needs and limits.
Financial strength that shields customers from volatility is part of it too. Solid reserves and careful management let an organization ride out market shocks without pushing every cost onto bills. That discipline comes out of her background in investment banking and private equity, where she learned to look hard at how capital gets deployed and at what makes one enterprise durable and another fragile.
During her tenure, annual revenue grew from about $385 million (FY2022) to more than $1 billion, and reserves grew from approximately $42 million (June 2022) to more than $500 million. The organization also earned an “A” credit rating with a stable outlook from S&P Global. A financial base like that protects customers and funds long-term clean energy investment at the same time, and it’s what makes big goals believable.
Finding the balance
No formula settles the balance between policy, technology and customers once and for all. Leaders keep working at it through listening, analysis and a readiness to adjust when conditions shift, all while juggling several priorities: moving climate goals forward, taking on promising technology responsibly, and protecting the affordability and reliability customers count on.
A few habits make that easier.
Ground decisions in data and financial analysis. Ambition has to stay tied to reality, and the numbers usually do the tying.
Engage stakeholders early. Bringing people in before decisions get made, instead of afterward, builds trust and brings problems to light before they turn into conflicts.
Pilot before scaling. Trying out new technologies and programs at a smaller scale holds down risk and builds the evidence needed to expand with confidence.
Communicate clearly, especially when tradeoffs are hard. Customers and policymakers are much more willing to back tough choices once they understand the reasons behind them.
None of these habits is complicated, but sticking with them under pressure is what keeps an organization durable. They also feed each other, since good data gives communication more credibility and early engagement makes pilots easier to design well.
The energy transition will keep testing leaders across the sector as policies change, technology improves and customers expect more. The organizations that come out ahead will be run by people who can see the full picture and pull competing priorities into balance. Burns doesn’t see that balance as a trade off between ambition and practicality, but rather that balance is the reason ambitious clean energy goals can deliver results that last.
Written in partnership with Tom White